- Abbott's Frozen Custard
- Adrian's Custard & Beef
- Alethea's Chocolates
- Antoinette Sweets
- Baskin-Robbins
- Beck's Creamery
- Ben & Jerry's Niagara Falls
- Bill Gray's
- Carvel Ice Cream Bakery
- Charlap's II
- Coasters Ice Cream Parlor
- Cold Stone Creamery
- Condrell's Candies & Ice Cream
- Custard Corner
- Custard Lite
- Dairy Queen
- Dippin' Dots
- Dolci Dessert Bakery and Gelateria
- Friendly's
- Great Lakes Station
- Green Acres Ice Cream
- Grumpy's Ice Cream
- Hanna's Frosty Treats
- Hershey's Coffee & Ice Cream
- Jamie's Ice Cream
- Jimmie's Ice Cream
- Kone King
- Lacey's Ice Cream Emporium
- Lake Effect Artisan Ice Cream
- Major Cool Off Ice Cream
- Melanie's Sweets Unlimited
- Mr Smoothie
- Nick Charlap's Ice Cream
- Pepe's Lemon Ice
- Route 16 Ice Cream
- Route 20 Ice Cream
- Sweet Jenny's
- Walden Ice Cream
- Wegmans
- Yogen Fruz